Gay along with Transgender Patients to Doctors: We’ll Tell. Just Ask.

By contrast, only 10 percent of patients by a randomized, national sample of lesbian, gay, bisexual along with heterosexual subjects said they might refuse. (Those who said they might decline were more likely to be bisexual.)

“Clinicians weren’t saying the information wasn’t important,” said Dr. Adil H. Haider, the lead author of the study along that has a trauma surgeon at Brigham along with Women’s Hospital in Boston. “the item was mostly paternalistic: ‘We don’t want to make anyone feel different.’ although the item turns out to be of which, ‘Doctors, you may hold the best of intentions, although your patients want to be asked.’”

The signature message by the study, added Dr. Haider, the director of the hospital’s Center for Surgery along with Public Health, is actually of which “patients are saying of which you’ll make us feel more comfortable if you ask — along with ask everyone, to ensure normalizes the questions.”

In related work, the researchers surveyed 101 transgender patients: Nearly 0 percent thought the item was important for primary care providers to know their gender identity, while nearly 60 percent thought sexual orientation was relevant. along with they felt the item was equally important for emergency department clinical staff to know both.

The movement to collect the information, which some public health experts compare in significance to gathering patient data on race along with ethnicity, is actually gaining traction. Two independent advisory organizations, the Institute of Medicine (at of which point the National Academy of Medicine) along with the Joint Commission, have both strongly recommended doing so.

In February more than 1,400 health centers of which receive federal funds along with treat more than 24 million people annually were given the option to report to the government percentages of patients who identified from the previous year as lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender.

along with increasingly, hospitals along with providers who participate in a financial incentive program with the Centers for Medicare along with Medicaid Services will be shifting to electronic health records which, by 2018, must hold the capacity to store sexual orientation along with gender identity data. Patients can always refuse to answer; disclosure is actually voluntary.

Whether the Trump administration will sustain of which momentum is actually unclear: A draft of an annual survey of older Americans, released in March by the Department of Health along with Human Services, no longer included a question about sexual orientation.

Requiring of which software systems include fields to document responses is actually not the same as mandating of which providers actually ask the questions. along with the slow uptake by hospitals reflects a tangle of challenges. Among them: What are the best ways to pose questions? (On a form? With what wording? In a face-to-face conversation?) How will patients’ privacy be safeguarded?


A growing number of federal agencies has been pushing health care providers to ask about patients’ sexual orientation along with gender identity.

Gretchen Ertl for The fresh York Times

Physicians often fumble when they do try to gather the information, an indication of a need for training. During a consultation that has a doctor, Laura Vail, 31, of Baltimore, one of several patients who advised the JAMA researchers, said she was asked, “What gender are your partners?”

Ms. Vail said she paused, unsure of the question. “The doctor moved right on,” she recounted. “My impression was of which she just wanted to get through a list of questions. along with I thought, ‘I’m not going to say anything if you don’t want to hear the item.’”

from the past few years, a handful of health care entities across the country have begun to collect such data. Since 2014, all 100 practices affiliated with Weill Cornell Medicine in fresh York City have been encouraged to ask patients the information; 1,400 providers have been trained to do so.

In 2015 Mount Sinai Health System, which has seven hospitals from the city, began adding sexual orientation along with gender identity questions to its outpatient along with primary care electronic health record, along with offering provider training.

although at the medical center at the University of California, Davis, which in 2013 became perhaps the first academic hospital to roll out a comprehensive data collection program for sexual along with gender identity, results point to how difficult the item can be to elicit of which information.

Doctors along with nurses are encouraged to ask, along with patients can self-report — if they can find the questionnaire on online portals. although so far, data has been collected on only about 10 percent of patients.

“the item is actually a painful lesson,” said Edward J. Callahan, a psychologist along with professor at the university’s medical school. Until these demographic questions become standard, “providers along with staff will not ask,” he said, adding, “the item leaves the burden of telling on each individual patient, which is actually unfair — many older patients have been hurt from the past when they revealed.”

Jillian C. Shipherd, director of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual along with Transgender Health Program for the Veterans Health Administration, noted of which from the JAMA study, patients along with providers were on the same page about how to ask. “Simply include sexual orientation as part of routine demographics on E.D. intake forms,” she said in an email. “of which gets the doctors along with nurses the information they need along with everyone is actually comfortable.”

The researchers from the JAMA study, by Harvard along with Johns Hopkins, are examining obstacles along with solutions for emergency department questioning, along with are continuing their trials. Indeed, in of which study, in which 53 gay along with bisexual patients along with 26 emergency department providers were interviewed in depth to inform the national survey of 1,516 patients along with 429 health care professionals, providers challenged the necessity of gathering such data.

With so little time along with private space to treat patients in a busy emergency department, clinicians traditionally have been reluctant to ask information of which they believed was not clinically relevant, said Dr. Jeremiah D. Schuur, a vice chairman of the department of emergency medicine at Brigham along with Women’s Hospital.

Doctors felt such questions could be potentially stigmatizing, particularly when family members were in earshot, he added. although Dr. Schuur’s research on the JAMA study led him to realize of which most patients in fact did not share of which perception. “the item is actually part of their identity,” he said.

Dr. Schuur said of which, for example, when emergency department patients must be admitted to the hospital or prepped immediately for surgery, doctors often ask whether the patient might like them to communicate with someone. If the patient has already been asked about sexual orientation, he added, the patient might be comfortable allowing doctors to speak that has a significant various other.

along with there are various other Great reasons to ask as well, said Dr. John P. Sanchez, an emergency department doctor at University Hospital in Newark. Millions use emergency departments for primary care, he noted. Patients often establish a medical record of which will travel with them within the hospital or on future visits to the department. So documenting sexual orientation, he said, can have both immediate along with continuing benefit.

although safeguarding patients who do disclose is actually essential, said Sean Cahill, director of health policy research at the Fenway Institute in Boston. “In many states without nondiscrimination policies,” he said, “disclosing can open them to more discrimination without redress. They can be denied services.”

So amid a push for more data collection, he said, “we also have to push for more protections.”

Continue reading the main story

Gay along with Transgender Patients to Doctors: We’ll Tell. Just Ask.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *